Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
House-Made Hush Puppies Plate
Pick 3 Seafoods
Rustic Mashed Potato
Coleslaw
About
Tally Fish House & Oyster Bar
Welcome to Tally Fish House & Oyster Bar, a culinary gem located at 6802 Thomasville Rd in Tallahassee, Florida. This vibrant establishment has quickly carved a niche for itself in the local dining scene, captivating diners with its fresh seafood offerings and warm, inviting atmosphere. Here, you can immerse yourself in the flavors of the coast while enjoying a laid-back vibe complemented by live music.
As you step inside, you’re greeted by an array of mouthwatering dishes, with standout menu options like shrimp and grits, renowned for their phenomenal seasoning and rich flavors. Guests rave about the shrimp quesadillas and irresistibly tasty crab legs, ensuring every visit is filled with delightful surprises. If you have a sweet tooth, do not miss the key lime pie—the perfect ending to a seafood feast.
What makes Tally Fish House & Oyster Bar truly special is not just its food, but its people. The staff, including the friendly bartender Mathew and the delightful manager Jalanie, create an atmosphere that feels like home. Patrons can enjoy refreshing cocktails like the spicy watermelon margarita while mingling in a space adorned with stunning local artwork from Lello Co., making each visit visually appealing as well.
While dining here, expect a community-oriented experience, highlighted by customer reviews expressing love for the service and the delicious offerings. Whether you’re there for brunch with family or a casual lunch with friends, Tally Fish House & Oyster Bar delivers an exceptional experience with every meal. With its commitment to quality food and a welcoming environment, this restaurant surely earns a spot on your must-visit list. Don’t forget to make your reservations and indulge in the culinary excellence of Tally Fish House & Oyster Bar!
Book a table
Make A Reservation
“ Food was good and staff were friendly. We were seated quickly for brunch and everything was tasty. There was no kids menu available; we over ordered & paid for the kids. Live music was going and the vibe was laid back, friendly & relaxed. The artwork by Lello Co. on the outside wall is amazing! I love to see local artists’ work appreciated by other locals. Very cool and a great reason to visit Tally Fish House! ”
“ Was having a day so I came here and was instantly served at the bar! The bar tender Mathew is so nice and he has great conversation! The manager Jalanie is such a doll everyone was kind food was great I had the shrimp and grits and I added eggs also a waffle on the side and had bottomless mimosas, sooo good! 10/10 ”
“ Love this place! We had excellent food! I highly recommend the shrimp quesadillas! The crab legs were tasty! Our oysters were fantastic! And then the key lime pie was the perfect finish! ”
“ We love Tally Fish house. Today, the shrimp and grits were phenomenal! And the sausage, oh my!! My husband said the sausage was exceptional. I love the light blackening on the shrimp. Also, thank you so much for bringing the drunken clams back. When we dine here, we order at least 2 every time. The fried shrimp are always yummy. We will keep coming back for the great food and service. We love listening to live music when you have it, too. ”
“ First time here but will not be the last! Great drinks. Loved my spicy watermelon margaritas and Hooter Brown on tap. Yes, please!! Great food and incredible service! Grouper bites did not disappoint and all of our entrees were fantastic. Smoked fish dip needed a little less mayo but other than that, was exceptional. Thanks Tori for going above and beyond and with a smile. ”
“ Amazing! Prompt service professional bartender and all the waitresses were beautiful especially my waitress Victoria. She was above and beyond expectations. Never kept me waiting on anything. Made me feel royal with her service Was my 2nd time visiting and will be back in November!! I really wished that you guys served stone crab claws. That will be an amazing plus to your services!! ”
“ This is my 2nd time in the same week. Visiting the area from out of state and friends recommended I try Tally’s. What a treat! Fantastic hush puppies, All-you-can eat shrimp (on thursdays) and the Brussels sprouts appetizer is literally amazing!! I would definitely come back next time I’m in the area. ”
“ Tally Fish House & Oyster Bar is a favorite of mine. I started off with Gator Bites. Then the choose two red snapper with sweet potato fries. They serve it with a melted marshmallow that compliments it so well. ”